"Catholics think the pope can't make mistakes." That is not what papal infallibility means.
Short answer: Papal infallibility means the Holy Spirit protects the pope from error when, as supreme teacher of the whole Church, he solemnly defines a doctrine of faith or morals by a definitive act. It does not mean he is sinless, inspired, or right about everything.
Key verses on papal infallibility
- "but I have prayed that your own faith may not fail; and once you have turned back, you must strengthen your brothers." (Luke 22:32)
- "and the gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against it." (Matthew 16:18)
- "Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven" (Matthew 16:19)
- "he will give you another Advocate to be with you always," (John 14:16)
- "But when he comes, the Spirit of truth, he will guide you to all truth." (John 16:13)
Scripture quotations are from the New American Bible, Revised Edition (NABRE), © 2010, 1991, 1986, 1970 Confraternity of Christian Doctrine, Washington, D.C. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
What Catholics Actually Teach
Infallibility belongs first to the whole Church. "Christ who is the Truth willed to confer on her a share in his own infallibility" (CCC 889). Its purpose is protective: to "preserve God's people from deviations and defections and to guarantee them the objective possibility of professing the true faith without error" (CCC 890).
The pope "enjoys this infallibility in virtue of his office" when, as "supreme pastor and teacher of all the faithful," he "proclaims by a definitive act a doctrine pertaining to faith or morals" (CCC 891). The same gift "is also present in the body of bishops when, together with Peter's successor, they exercise the supreme Magisterium," above all "in an Ecumenical Council" (CCC 891).
The First Vatican Council defined this in 1870 (Pastor Aeternus, chapter 4). In summary: the pope teaches infallibly when he speaks ex cathedra ("from the chair"), that is, when acting as pastor and teacher of all Christians, he uses his supreme apostolic authority to define a doctrine of faith or morals to be held by the whole Church. Such definitions are irreformable "of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church," as Vatican II restated (Lumen Gentium 25).
What Catholics do not teach:
- Impeccability. Infallibility protects teaching, not behavior. Popes sin and go to confession.
- Inspiration. The pope does not write new Scripture. Vatican I itself says the Holy Spirit was not promised to St. Peter's successors so that they might make known new doctrine by His revelation, but so that they might guard and faithfully explain the revelation handed down through the apostles. "No new public revelation is to be expected" (CCC 66).
- That every papal word is infallible. Interviews, homilies, and private opinions are not definitions. But the ordinary teaching of the pope, and of the bishops in communion with him, still calls for "religious assent," "which, though distinct from the assent of faith, is nonetheless an extension of it" (CCC 892).
- That the pope is above Scripture. "This Magisterium is not superior to the Word of God, but is its servant" (CCC 86).
The Biblical Case
1. Jesus prayed that St. Peter's faith would not fail
"Simon, Simon, behold Satan has demanded to sift all of you like wheat, but I have prayed that your own faith may not fail; and once you have turned back, you must strengthen your brothers" (Luke 22:31–32). The NABRE note explains that "all of you" renders a plural "you." Satan targets all the apostles; Jesus prays for St. Peter in particular and charges him to strengthen the rest. Yet He foretells St. Peter's denial in the same breath. St. Peter's personal failure and his protected role stand side by side.
2. The keys and binding authority
"I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven" (Matthew 16:19). If St. Peter could bind the Church to a false doctrine, heaven would be ratifying error. Infallibility is simply the guarantee that this cannot happen when the keys are used to define the faith.
3. The Spirit will guide the apostles "to all truth"
At the Last Supper, Jesus promises "another Advocate to be with you always" (John 14:16), who "will teach you everything and remind you of all that [I] told you" (John 14:26), and "will guide you to all truth" (John 16:13). "Always" reaches beyond the apostles' lifetimes (compare Matthew 28:20).
4. The Church cannot be overcome
"The gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against" the Church (Matthew 16:18), and St. Paul calls the Church "the pillar and foundation of truth" (1 Timothy 3:15). A pillar that could bind believers to error would not hold up the truth. (See Is the Church the Pillar and Foundation of Truth?)
5. God can speak truly through flawed men
Jesus says: "The scribes and the Pharisees have taken their seat on the chair of Moses. Therefore, do and observe all things whatsoever they tell you, but do not follow their example" (Matthew 23:2–3). And Caiaphas, who plotted Jesus' death, spoke a true prophecy: "He did not say this on his own, but since he was high priest for that year, he prophesied that Jesus was going to die for the nation" (John 11:51). The gift attaches to the office, not to the holder's holiness.
Objections Answered
(a) "Pope Honorius taught heresy."
At its strongest: In the 630s Pope Honorius I wrote to Sergius, patriarch of Constantinople, and acknowledged one will in Christ, language the Monothelite heresy used. The Third Council of Constantinople (681) anathematized him by name for what he wrote to Sergius, judging that he had followed and confirmed Sergius's error. Pope St. Leo II confirmed the council. How can a pope be infallible if a council condemned one for heresy?
Answer: Catholics take the condemnation seriously. But notice what Honorius did not do. He did not define a doctrine for the whole Church by a definitive act. He wrote to one patriarch about a dispute he hoped to calm. Catholic defenders note that his stated reason was that Christ took our nature without its sin, which suggests he was denying a sinful, conflicting will in Christ rather than a human will. Critics reply that his wording still gave cover to heresy, and the council judged it so. St. Leo II, confirming the council, described Honorius's fault as failing to teach the apostolic tradition and allowing the faith to be defiled. That is a real papal failure, but not an infallible definition of heresy. Infallibility never promised that popes would always speak well. It promised that a definitive papal definition of faith would not be false, and Honorius never issued one on this question.
And look at who settled the question. The council that condemned Honorius received a letter from Pope St. Agatho, one of Honorius's successors, defending the two wills of Christ. It describes the faith "established upon the firm rock of this Church of blessed Peter, the Prince of the Apostles, which by his grace and guardianship remains free from all error." The case the critics cite most is a case where Rome's definitive teaching held, and a pope's private failure was named and corrected.
(b) "Paul rebuked Peter, so Peter wasn't infallible."
At its strongest: "And when Cephas came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face because he clearly was wrong" (Galatians 2:11). The first pope was publicly corrected.
Answer: Read the next verse. St. Peter "began to draw back and separated himself, because he was afraid of the circumcised" (Galatians 2:12). The fault was conduct under pressure. St. Paul's charge is that St. Peter was "living like a Gentile" and still pressuring Gentiles (Galatians 2:14), which assumes St. Peter knew the right doctrine. He had taught it at the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15:7). A pope can sin and deserve correction. For more on this passage, see Is the Papacy in the Bible?
(c) "Only God is infallible."
At its strongest: Every human being is fallible. Claiming infallibility for a man puts him where only God belongs.
Answer: Protestants already believe God used fallible men to write inerrant Scripture. Infallibility is a lesser gift: not inspiration, but protection from error in a definitive act. The council in Acts 15 bound the Churches with the words, "It is the decision of the holy Spirit and of us" (Acts 15:28). The infallibility is God's; the Church only guards His truth.
(d) "Infallibility was invented in 1870."
At its strongest: The First Vatican Council defined papal infallibility only in 1870, over the objections of some bishops. The Eastern Orthodox never accepted it. If it were apostolic, why did it take eighteen centuries to define?
Answer: The formal definition is from 1870. That is true, and it proves nothing against the doctrine. The Church defines when a truth is challenged. The word homoousios ("one in being with the Father") was defined at Nicaea in 325, but the Church had always worshiped Christ as God. The same pattern holds here. Scripture already gives the substance: Jesus prays that St. Peter's faith "may not fail" and charges him to strengthen the rest (Luke 22:32); He gives St. Peter the keys and promises that what he binds is bound in heaven (Matthew 16:19); and when the first council debated circumcision, it was St. Peter who stood and declared, "we believe that we are saved through the grace of the Lord Jesus, in the same way as they" (Acts 15:11), after which "the whole assembly fell silent" (Acts 15:12). The Fathers below show the same conviction long before 1870: the faith of St. Peter's Church cannot fail. Vatican I named the gift. It did not invent it.
The Early Church Agrees
The term "papal infallibility" is later. The conviction is not. The early witnesses below treat the faith of St. Peter's Church as a sure standard, and treat a Roman definition as St. Peter speaking.
- St. Irenaeus (Against Heresies 3.3.2, c. AD 180): "For it is a matter of necessity that every Church should agree with this Church, on account of its preeminent authority."
- St. Cyprian of Carthage (Epistle 54.14, c. AD 252), about schismatics who appealed to Rome: they sailed "to the throne of Peter, and to the chief church whence priestly unity takes its source," forgetting that the Romans were those "to whom faithlessness could have no access."
- Council of Chalcedon (451), Session II: after the letter of Pope St. Leo the Great on Christ's two natures was read, the bishops cried out: "This is the faith of the fathers, this is the faith of the Apostles. ... Peter has spoken thus through Leo." A council made up overwhelmingly of Eastern bishops heard a Roman doctrinal letter as St. Peter's own voice.
- Pope St. Agatho (letter to the emperors, read at the Third Council of Constantinople, 680): the orthodox faith "has been established upon the firm rock of this Church of blessed Peter, the Prince of the Apostles, which by his grace and guardianship remains free from all error."
Conclusion
Papal infallibility is narrower than its critics think and more biblical than many realize. It does not make popes sinless or wise in everything. It means that when St. Peter's successor definitively teaches the whole Church what it must believe, Christ does not let him lead it into error.
If you are Protestant, you already trust that God protected fallible men when they wrote Scripture. Consider that the Lord who prayed for St. Peter's faith still keeps His word for St. Peter's flock.
Come home. The gift Christ gave St. Peter to strengthen his brothers did not die with him; it still guards the faith through his successor, the bishop of Rome, in the Catholic Church. Christ did not found many churches. He founded one, on St. Peter and the apostles (Matthew 16:18), and that Church is the Catholic Church. "It is through Christ's Catholic Church alone, which is the universal help toward salvation, that the fullness of the means of salvation can be obtained" (CCC 816). If you are a baptized Christian, you already share "a certain, although imperfect, communion" with her (CCC 838). Every truth you already hold is a call to the rest of the way. Christ is calling you into the Catholic Church.
Your next step: Come to Mass this Sunday at your local Catholic church. You can find one near you at MassTimes.org. Everyone is welcome; if you're not yet Catholic, pray with us but don't receive Communion yet. When you're ready to become Catholic, call the parish office and ask about OCIA, the Order of Christian Initiation of Adults. They will walk you through every step. Read our guide: How Do I Become Catholic? Not ready yet? Get our free pocket guide below and keep learning.
FAQ
How often has a pope spoken infallibly? Rarely. The two most commonly cited solemn definitions are the Immaculate Conception (1854; CCC 491) and the Assumption (1950; CCC 966). Theologians discuss whether a few other acts qualify.
Can a pope change doctrine? No. Infallibility "extends as far as does the deposit of divine Revelation"; "it also extends to all those elements of doctrine, including morals, without which the saving truths of the faith cannot be preserved, explained, or observed" (CCC 2035). A definition clarifies what was handed down; it never creates new revelation (CCC 66).
Are bishops infallible too? Not individually. But the bishops teach infallibly together with the pope, whether gathered in an ecumenical council or "even though dispersed through the world," when "they are in agreement on one position as definitively to be held" (Lumen Gentium 25; CCC 891).
Sources
Scripture (NABRE, bible.usccb.org): Matthew 16:18–19; Matthew 23:2–3; Matthew 28:20; Luke 22:31–32 (with NABRE notes); John 11:49–52; John 14:16, 26; John 16:13; Acts 15:7, 11–12, 28; Galatians 2:11–14; 1 Timothy 3:15.
Catechism of the Catholic Church (vatican.va): 66; 86; 491; 816, 838; 889, 890, 891, 892; 966; 2035.
Councils (vatican.va): First Vatican Council, Pastor Aeternus (1870), ch. 4 (Latin); Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium 25.
Church Fathers and councils (newadvent.org): St. Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.3.2 (ANF vol. 1); St. Cyprian, Epistle 54 (ANF vol. 5); Council of Chalcedon (451) (NPNF2 vol. 14); Third Council of Constantinople (680–681), including the letter of Pope St. Agatho (NPNF2 vol. 14).